Advertising in the past (especially from the likes of Procter & Gamble) frequently featured a format known as Problem – Solution. The Problem would be dramatised in a way first to get heads nodding – oh-yes-I-have-those-stubborn-stains-too-but-never-dared-mention-them. Then, in a starburst of glory, the Solution would enter the screen in a heroic pose, possibly accompanied by a man in a white coat or a super-scientific nifty demo.
Once super-hero Solution had done its job, the end benefit would be celebrated with cheesy smiles all around (particularly if the Problem was unsightly yellow stains on teeth, or similar.)
However, after a while, ‘Problem Fatigue’ began to set into that style of advertising. Most of the world’s household stain problems, washday woes and less-than-perfect skin, hair and teeth gripes had been tackled, if not completely eradicated by the various solutions on offer. Companies started inventing problems to which they’d already made the solution. Or dilemmas which no normal person in their right mind would ever entertain. It all got a bit ludicrous.
But a few years ago, advertisers started to strike a rich seam. Problems – less physical, more attitudinal – that the advertising and marketing industry had themselves created.
Take the picture above. Back in the 80s, 90s and even early noughties, clothes and toys for young children were fairly gender-neutral. With a few notable exceptions. But for the last couple of decades, more and more sparkly pink and girl/boy-designated books, toys, birthday cards, wrapping paper and even cakes and sweets have crept in. So, all of a sudden, there’s an issue – gender stereotyping – that brands can bravely fight against. While keeping quiet about who created the problem in the first place.
Ditto Objectified Women in Advertising. There are more than a few plucky brands taking a stand against this issue. Accompanying their efforts is a narrative that suggests that back in the dark ages of the last century, almost all women in advertising looked something like this, unless they were cast into the role of mother/housewife:
And, worst of all, women at the time meekly accepted their lot of how they were portrayed. Really? Maybe most of us had more important things than advertising to worry our pretty little heads about at the time.
While we’re on the subject of women, there are those now well-known enemies: flawless beauty:
Again, these ‘issues’ – which were manufactured by the advertising industry itself – are being used as societal problems which the new, virtuous, purpose-led brands can rush in and solve in a blaze of awards, social experiments and tear-jerking commercials.
What takes real bravery, though, is to admit to having created (or exacerbated) a real problem, like plastic waste, or unnecessary additives in foods and make a commitment to do something about it:
Sometimes the world of advertising, with its issues, problems and solutions, feels rather like the world of reality TV, where the winners of one ghastly show are recycled as contestants for the next.
And no-one outside the echo chamber really cares.
Originally Posted on http://secretagencyblog.blogspot.com/This post was originally published on this site